[Peter Lurye]

Petter wrote:

The ability to mute notes in the Grid Editor was added in Superior Drummer version 3.3.0 in case you missed it!

WOW!! Faith in humanity restored—thanks! Also love the new MIDI tab in the Grooves Pane. SD3 is the best…

Cheers,

Peter

[Peter Lurye]

Jacy Smith wrote:

Peter Lurye wrote:

shapeshifterlive wrote:

Hi There, has this been implemented yet? Started editing on grid editor..the best for drums I’ve seen, but.. reeeeally need that mute feature 🙂 many thanks

It hasn’t. Can I suggest you file a support ticket to request it?

PL

That’s what this section of the forum (ie. Requests and Feedback) is for.

Indeed. I submitted a support ticket on this subject anyway. However, based on Scott’s recent response (as evidence that Toontrack is reading these messages), perhaps it’s not necessary…

[Peter Lurye]

shapeshifterlive wrote:

Hi There, has this been implemented yet? Started editing on grid editor..the best for drums I’ve seen, but.. reeeeally need that mute feature 🙂 many thanks

It hasn’t. Can I suggest you file a support ticket to request it?

PL

[Peter Lurye]

JD_51 wrote:

Imagine paying hundreds of dollars on SD3 and not being able to toggle a Mute tool. The workflow on this “top of the line” software is garbage. Should’ve researched more before I bought.

• This post was modified 3 years ago by JD_51.

Respectfully, I gotta say I think that’s a pretty huge exaggeration. 🙂 I personally think SD3 is a mind-blowingly well-designed piece of software, which is why the lack of ability to mute notes in the grid editor is such a perplexing deficiency.  Don’t get me wrong—no one wants this feature more than I do, but I wouldn’t indict the whole VI for that…

PL

[Peter Lurye]

rootbass wrote:

I wanted to share a trick that I use, as it doesn’t seem like an additional request for note mute is going to do much good here haha

I just throw one element into the kit that I’m not going to use and leave the whole instrument muted. Then, I highlight the note(s) I want to mute and use the up or down arrow keys to move the selection to that muted channel without changing its location on the grid. Then you can easily move it back to the same spot on the original channel.

It’s a little more time consuming than being able to mute, but it’s still a pretty easy way to A/B ideas, like “Is it better with that extra kick hit in there?” (usually not ha)

Clever partial work-around–thanks! Sadly, not quite a substitute for true muting. Let’s say your groove has 8 different hihat strokes, and you’ve dragged a few of them to the “dummy” instrument you mention. Now you want to drag them back. You have to remember which strokes you dragged away, which would certainly be beyond my memory skills, anyway. I must say it is DEEPLY aggravating that 3.2.5 was just released, and muting notes in the grid editor wasn’t added. Anyway, I appreciate the out-of-the-box (off-the-grid?) thinking…

PL

• This post was modified 3 years, 2 months ago by Peter Lurye.

[Peter Lurye]

PhilGDCT wrote:

Well, this post has been running for 2 years now… any hope of this feature becoming reality? Muting notes in the grid editor is way past due.

As a work-around, I’ve been selecting the “diamond” notes in the Grid Editor, then, in the velocity window, drag the mouse over all of the now blue note velocities (which is easy to do, and you don’t have to change each note individually), and drag the velocities to zero. It’s not perfect, yet it does allow me to keep the notes in place on the grid editor, and listen without the (now muted) notes. This only works well if all of the velocities are the same though. For myself, this is better than deleting and adding notes.

• The post has been modified 3 years, 9 months ago by PhilGDCT"> 2 times, last modified 3 years, 9 months ago by PhilGDCT.

Interesting technique! The only issue I see is that it would make it hard to tell at a glance which notes you’ve “muted” this way. In any case, I still feel as strongly about this issue as when I first commented on it, in 2019. BTW your dates are not quite right—this thread was started at the end of 2017(!), so it’s been over three years since the original post. The clock is ticking… 🙂

Peter

• This post was modified 3 years, 9 months ago by Peter Lurye.

[Peter Lurye]

John Baker Baker wrote:

Also, it would be very helpful to be able to select separate tools (pointer, pencil, mute) quickly and toggle between them by holding down a key temporarily. For example, if the pointer tool is the default tool, holding down “control” would temporarily enable. the pencil tool; “option” would temporarily enable the mute tool.

Agreed— +1.

[Peter Lurye]

Has this been added yet? If not, please add me to the list who very strongly want this feature!

Thanks,

Peter

[Author]

Replies