2

[Dan Wilson]

Hi Rallyboy,

Really liked the song. The BGV at 2 and 4 minutes where very nice I think they really fit with the dreamy feel you are trying to evoke seems like you could visit it once more within the body of the song. As for the middle section why not explore using the vibrato guitar there, as an example listen to what you were doing at around 3 minutes. If I could given one small constructive criticism – that is to fade the morse code part a little earlier since it is more straight time and the rest of the song has more swing to it, I think it takes away from the groove of the song.

I hope I haven’t offended with what I wrote above.

Dan

Logic X, SD3, SD2, iMac

[Dan Wilson]

Hi Rallyboy,

I enjoyed listening to the tune. I like how you balanced the mix, I could hear every instrument without anyone overpowering the others.

Dan

Logic X, SD3, SD2, iMac

[Dan Wilson]

Hi Rallyboy101,

First of all, thank you for the constructive criticism, I really appreciate it. After reading it, I played around with the mix a bit more. Hopefully it moved in the right direction.
The bass is a DI p-bass played by my brother. The chain is DI into MOTU 828x into logic x. Plugins include the waves Puigtech Eqs and IK Black76 and White 2A with a bit of parallel compression.

Any further constructive criticism will be most appreciated.

Cheers
Dan

Logic X, SD3, SD2, iMac

[Dan Wilson]

Hi Matthew,

Thank you for the advice, especially about the entry/passing words and the level of the vocals relative to the music. I will look closer at this and arrangement suggestions on the next song.

Your constructive criticisms was what I was hoping for.

Cheers

Dan

Logic X, SD3, SD2, iMac

[Dan Wilson]

Hi Scott,

Absolutely, but what if you say wanted to use two different eq or compressor settings on your top and bottom snare mics. You could at present send each mic to a different stereo bus in SD2 and the out to logic (DAW) but you end up with a bunch of stereo busses for mono mics. I am merely suggesting if one could access their third party plugins within SD2 it would be much more elegant.
I suppose then, of course, people would ask that they be able to access the kick track in SD2 from the bass compressor so they could duck the bass in the their DAW. I realize it is a never ending “how about…”. This was only a thought after using SD2 and truly liking the end result, but to get there is was just a little cumbersome.

Dan Wilson

Logic X, SD3, SD2, iMac

[Author]

Replies